Butler Bay
Windermere, Orange County, FL$800K - $3.5M
—
Median Price
Coming soon
—
Active Listings
Coming soon
—
Avg. Days on Market
Coming soon
—
School Rating
Coming soon
Walk Score
About Butler Bay
Butler Bay is a prestigious, established community nestled along the shores of Lake Crescent in the charming town of Windermere. Known for its expansive lots, mature oak trees, and custom-built estate homes, this neighborhood offers residents a tranquil and private lifestyle. The community features a mix of architectural styles, from traditional Florida homes to Mediterranean-inspired estates, many of which boast private boat docks and stunning water views.
Residents of Butler Bay enjoy access to the pristine Butler Chain of Lakes, making it a paradise for boating, fishing, and water sports enthusiasts. The neighborhood is also home to a private community park, tennis courts, and a fishing pier, providing ample opportunities for outdoor recreation. Its prime location offers a peaceful retreat while remaining conveniently close to the upscale shopping, dining, and entertainment options in nearby Dr. Phillips and Winter Garden.
Families are drawn to Butler Bay not only for its beautiful homes and natural surroundings but also for its zoning to some of Orange County's top-rated public schools. The community's strong sense of neighborhood pride and active homeowners association contribute to a welcoming and well-maintained environment, making it one of Windermere's most sought-after addresses.
Neighborhood Highlights
- Direct access to the Butler Chain of Lakes
- Large, mature lots with custom estate homes
- Private community park and tennis courts
- Zoned for top-rated Orange County public schools
- Close proximity to downtown Windermere and Dr. Phillips
Property Types
ZIP Codes
Schools Serving This Neighborhood
District: Orange County Public Schools
Zoned for Orange County Public Schools schools. View schools on GreatSchools →
School ratings and boundaries change — visit GreatSchools.org for current information.
Search All Schools in WindermereSchool data provided in partnership with GreatSchools.org
Interested in Butler Bay?
Get personalized listings and neighborhood insights from a local expert.
Or call us directly:
(407) 490-0397Frequently Asked Questions About Butler Bay
Does Butler Bay have access to the Butler Chain of Lakes?
Yes, Butler Bay offers direct access to the Butler Chain of Lakes. Many homes are situated on Lake Crescent, and the community features a private boat ramp and fishing pier for residents.
What are the HOA fees in Butler Bay?
HOA fees in Butler Bay are generally considered reasonable for a luxury community in Windermere. They cover the maintenance of common areas, the community park, and tennis courts.
What schools are zoned for Butler Bay?
Butler Bay is zoned for highly rated Orange County public schools, typically including Windermere Elementary, Bridgewater Middle, and Windermere High School. However, zoning can change, so it's always best to verify with the school district.
Are there community amenities in Butler Bay?
Yes, residents enjoy access to a private community park, tennis courts, a fishing pier, and a boat ramp. The neighborhood's mature landscaping and quiet streets also make it ideal for walking and cycling.